In March 2020, the federal government expanded Medicare-subsidised telehealth services in order to avoid the unnecessary exposure of patients and healthcare professionals to COVID-19.
As of January 2022, many of these expansions have become a permanent component of Medicare (DoHaAC 2022).
Therefore, if your organisation offers telehealth services, you should know which technology, equipment and software to use, how to set it up and how to ensure video and audio are high-quality.
What is Telehealth?
Telehealth is the remote delivery of healthcare using information and communication technologies. Telehealth services may include virtual consultations, remote patient monitoring and maintenance of electronic patient health records (Mayo Clinic 2022).
In the past, virtual consultations delivered through video conferencing were often used for patients in rural and remote areas so that they could receive care without travelling (RACGP 2019).
However, since the COVID-19 pandemic, telehealth has now been adapted more widely across the healthcare sector.
Therefore, it is of utmost importance that healthcare professionals and staff are familiar with the technology and equipment required, and have the knowledge and skills necessary to utilise it effectively for the delivery of high-quality remote care.
What is Required for a Video Consultation Set-Up?
In order to deliver virtual consultations through video-conferencing, your organisation should have:
- An appropriate consultation space that includes:
- Arrangements for privacy protection (e.g. screens, doors)
- Good lighting
- Plain decor that will not be distracting
- Access to any medical equipment that may be required
- Measures to prevent disruption (e.g. ‘do not disturb’ signs)
- Access to a phone as a back-up
- Appropriate hardware (i.e. computer)
- Appropriate video software
- A high-quality webcam
- A high-quality microphone (built-in or external) with echo-cancelling properties
- Access to technical support and troubleshooting guides.
(RACGP 2019)
What Does a Video Consultation Involve?
Video consultations should generally be delivered similarly to any other consultation, in-line with the current best-practice models of care. Recommendations for assessment, clarification of diagnoses and recommendations for treatment and review should be effectively communicated as per usual (RACP 2020).
The limitations of telehealth mean that advanced communication skills are necessary so that health professionals can compensate for the lack of visual cues (Morony et al. 2018).
Maintaining Patient Privacy
Privacy is an important consideration in telehealth, and the confidentiality and privacy of patients should be protected at all times. Video consultations are subject to the same standards and government legislation as regular consultations in regards to privacy, consent and confidentiality (RACGP 2020).
The following measures should be taken to ensure patient privacy:
- A dedicated, undisturbed space for consultations should be established. Other people should not be able to hear or view the consultation.
- Technology should be fit for clinical purposes and facilitate safety and privacy.
- Consultations should be recorded and stored securely.
(RACGP 2020; RACP 2020)
Technical Considerations
In general, the technology and equipment used during virtual consultations should be reliable, compatible with the patient’s technology, high-quality and secure to ensure privacy and confidentiality (RACP 2020).
Poor sound and visuals can be distracting, annoying and may hinder the consultation (RACGP 2019).
Below are some tips from the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners (2019) for maximising video and audio quality during virtual consultations:
Visual
- Ensure lighting is good enough for faces to be clearly visible
- Ask participants to move in or out of frame when necessary
- The camera angle should be adjusted so that the healthcare professional and patient can make eye-contact
- Ensure all parties avoid bright or reflective clothing, as this may affect camera focus
- Ensure the camera is able to focus in on different areas if needed
- Ensure you are able to share screens to display relevant information or records if necessary.
Audio
- Participants using an external microphone should place it close to themselves on a firm, flat surface close to minimise background noise and ensure good-quality audio
- Participants should speak clearly at a normal volume
- Participants should switch mobile phones off or to silent
- Microphones should be muted when not speaking so that the other party can be heard clearly
- Participants should try to minimise unnecessary background noises (e.g. typing on a keyboard).
(RACGP 2019)
Conducting a Video Consultation
The following is a general guide from the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners (2021) for conducting a video consultation.
Before the Consultation:
- Ensure the consultation room is appropriately set up, keeping in mind privacy and audio and visual quality
- Test your technology
- Bring up the patient’s health record and phone number (in case the connection fails).
Starting and Conducting the Consultation:
- Commence the consultation by calling/inviting the patient
- Confirm visual and audio quality is satisfactory
- Ask the patient for verbal informed consent for the consultation
- Ask if the patient is happy to proceed, addressing any privacy concerns they may have. Ensure the patient is in a private space
- Begin the consultation.
Closing the Consultation:
- Summarise the key points from the consultation, including any agreed follow-ups such as future appointments, prescriptions and referrals
- Ask the patient if they have any further questions or need any clarification
- Advise the patient that you are ending the consultation
- Once the consultation is over, complete any necessary follow-ups (e.g. sending referrals or writing prescriptions)
- Update the patient’s health records
- Note any technical issues and report them to your organisation’s designated support person.
(RACGP 2021)
Choosing Video Conference Software
The software used for video conferences should be safe, secure and effective. There is specialised telehealth software available, but you may alternatively choose to use general (non-medical) video conferencing software such as Skype, WhatsApp or FaceTime (RACGP 2020).
According to the RACGP (2020), there is currently no evidence to suggest that the video software listed above is unsuitable for clinical use. The Australasian College of Rural & Remote Medicine (2020) has advised that it is ‘reasonably safe at the present time’ to use general video conferencing software for calls. As most video conferencing software uses encryption during transmission, the risk of interception is minimal if there is a direct connection between both ends of the call.
However, the ACRRM does recommend that providers do not use the file transfer or text chat features of software such as Skype, WhatsApp or Facetime for clinical purposes because they are much more vulnerable to security breaches than video calls (ACRRM 2020).
It is important to use your own judgment when choosing software. Any potential privacy risks to the patient should be evaluated when necessary.
The Australian Psychological Society (2017) provides three principles to guide the selection of appropriate video conferencing software for telehealth. These are:
1. When selecting software, providers should take a client-centered approach:
- There should be minimal or no set-up cost to the client
- The software should accessible through a variety of internet browsers and devices
- The software should successfully operate and provide high-quality video and audio in consideration of the bandwidth available in rural and remote areas
- The software should be simple for clients to install, access and operate.
2. The software should be fit for purpose, meaning it should:
- Be secure
- Minimise interruptions and dropouts
- Facilitate high-quality and reliable audio and video transfer
- Be compatible between platforms (e.g. Windows and macOS)
- Allow group-based services
- Be cost-effective
- Provide technical support.
Providers will also need to consider how often software updates are needed and if they will cause disruption to telehealth services, and whether training will be required in order for staff to use the software.
3. The software should facilitate the security and privacy of clients, including:
- Secure transfer of information from end-to-end that complies with the Australian Privacy Principle 11 of the Privacy Act 1998 (Commonwealth)
- Strong passwords, two-factor authentication and an audit trail
- Security measures that can be regularly updated to protect against malware, viruses, intrusions etc.
(APS 2017)
The following is an overview of some popular software that you may choose to use, including both general and telehealth-specific software. Please note this is not an exhaustive list. Use your own discretion when choosing which software is most appropriate for your own organisation.
Coreplus
Cost:
- Basic plan: $5 per user per month
- Standard plan: $25 per user per month
- eHealth plan: $45 per user per month
- Group plan: Price on application
- Free trial available.
Pros:
- Specifically designed for telehealth
- Practice management software that is integrated into GP/specialist and hospital systems
- Secure messaging
- Integrates billing, claims and payments
- Capability for add-ons and custom integrations
- Automated workflows
- Allows for easy e-referrals
- Booking platform for patients.
Cons:
- Paid software.
Coviu
Cost:
- Essentials plan: $20 per user per month
- Standard plan: $40 per user per month
- Premium plan: $55 per user per month
- Enterprise plan: Custom pricing
- Free trial for 2 weeks.
Pros:
- Specifically designed for telehealth
- End-to-end encryption
- No patient data stored
- Patients do not need to log in.
Cons:
- Paid software.
FaceTime
Cost: Free
Pros:
- Comes already installed on iOS devices
- Free calls over Wi-Fi
- Up to 32 people can join a call
- Convenient and widespread software.
Cons:
- Available for Apple devices only (Mac computers, iOS devices)
- Not specifically for healthcare purposes.
Healthdirect Video Call
Cost: Free* (for eligible healthcare services)
Pros:
- Specifically designed for telehealth
- Provides an access link on practice’s homepage
- Provides a virtual waiting room
- Patients only need a web browser - no software or account is required
- Secure.
Cons:
- Can not be freely downloaded - access must be granted after making an enquiry.
Skype
Cost: Free for video calls (with some paid features)
Pros:
- Video calls, audio calls and messages to other Skype users are free
- Multiple people can join a call (up to 50 for audio calls)
- Convenient and widespread software
- A good low-risk entry point to video conferencing.
Cons:
- Not specifically for healthcare purposes
- Voice mail, SMS texts and calling non-Skype users is a paid feature.
Cost: Free
Pros:
- Free
- Convenient and widespread software.
Cons:
- Not specifically for healthcare purposes.
Zoom (Basic)
Cost: Free
Pros:
- Free
- Unlimited one-on-one meetings
- Group meetings of up to 100 people for up to 40 minutes.
Cons:
- Not specifically for healthcare purposes
- Less features available than the healthcare version.
Zoom for Healthcare
Cost:
- Zoom One Pro: $209.90 per user per year
- Zoom One Business:From $279.90 per user per year.
Pros:
- Enables HIPAA compliance
- Specifically designed for telehealth.
Cons:
- Paid software.
Topics
References
- Apple 2023, FaceTime User Guide, Apple, viewed 13 April 2023, https://support.apple.com/en-au/guide/facetime/welcome/mac
- Australasian College of Rural & Remote Medicine 2020, ACRRM Advice on Risk Management When Using Video Conferencing Software for Clinical Video Consultations, Australasian College of Rural & Remote Medicine, viewed 13 April 2023, https://www.acrrm.org.au/docs/default-source/all-files/acrrm_risk-management_clinical-video-consultations-factsheet_final.pdf?sfvrsn=dfb6190a_4
- The Australian Psychological Society 2017, Principles for Choosing Videoconferencing Technology, APS, viewed 13 April 2023, https://psychology.org.au/psychology/medicare-rebates-psychological-services/medicare-faqs-for-the-public/telehealth-services/principles-choosing-videoconferencing-technology
- Coreplus 2023, Coreplus [website], viewed 13 April 2023.
- Coviu 2023, Coviu [website], viewed 13 April 2023.
- Department of Health and Aged Care 2022, Telehealth, Australian Government, viewed 13 April 2023, https://www.health.gov.au/topics/health-technologies-and-digital-health/about/telehealth
- Healthdirect 2023, Video Call, Australian Government, viewed 13 April 2023, https://about.healthdirect.gov.au/video-call
- Mayo Clinic 2022, Telehealth: Technology Meets Care, Mayo Clinic, viewed 13 April 2023, https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/consumer-health/in-depth/telehealth/art-20044878
- Morony, S, Weir, K, Duncan, G, Biggs, J, Nutbeam, D & Mccaffrey, K 2018, Enhancing ‘Communication Skills for Telehealth: Development and Implementation of a Teach-Back Intervention for a National Maternal and Child Health Helpline in Australia’, BMC Health Services Research, vol. 18, no, 162, viewed 13 April 2023, https://bmchealthservres.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12913-018-2956-6
- The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners 2020, Guide to Providing Telephone and Video Consultations in General Practice, Royal Australian College of General Practitioners, viewed 13 April 2023, https://www.racgp.org.au/FSDEDEV/media/documents/Clinical%20Resources/Guidelines/Guide-to-providing-telephone-and-video-consultations.pdf
- Royal Australian College of General Practitioners 2021, Guide to Providing Telephone and Video Consultations in General Practice: Flowcharts, Royal Australian College of General Practitioners, viewed 13 April 2023, https://www.racgp.org.au/FSDEDEV/media/documents/Clinical%20Resources/Guidelines/Telephone-and-video-consultations-in-general-practice-Flowcharts.pdf
- The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners 2019, Telehealth Video Consultations Guide, Royal Australian College of General Practitioners, viewed 13 April 2023, https://www.racgp.org.au/getmedia/764ab82e-7dea-434e-94ca-cab808f7b5eb/Telehealth-video-consultations-guide.pdf.aspx
- The Royal Australasian College of Physicians 2020, Telehealth Guidelines and Practical Tips, The Royal Australasian College of Physicians, viewed 13 April 2023, https://www.racp.edu.au//docs/default-source/advocacy-library/telehealth-guidelines-and-practical-tips.pdf?sfvrsn=daa2f1a_18
- Skype 2023, Skype [website], viewed 13 April 2023.
- WhatsApp 2023, WhatsApp [website], viewed 13 April 2023.
- Zoom 2023, Zoom [website], viewed 13 April 2023.
Additional Resources
- ACRRM Advice on Risk Management When Using Video Conferencing Software for Clinical Video Consultations | ACRRM
- Principles for Choosing Videoconferencing Technology | APS
- Guide to Providing Telephone and Video Consultations in General Practice | RACGP
- Guide to Telehealth Video Consultations | RACGP
- Telephone and Video Consultations in General Practice: Flowcharts | RACGP
- Telehealth Communication Skills | Ausmed Article